• JOURNAL
  • ARCHIVE
  • ABOUT
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • CONTACT
Menu

Wenglinsky Review

Culture, Social Structure & Politics from a Sociology Professor
  • JOURNAL
  • ARCHIVE
  • ABOUT
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • CONTACT

Ellsworth Kelly, Blue White, 1962. Oil on canvas. Rose Art Museum.

Thought-Provoking Essays Include: Continuous Disabilities, Fascist Science Fiction, The Politics of Drag Queens, Thomas Cole’s The Voyage of Life,  The Fundamentals of Social Roles,  Radical Sociology,   Women Are An Attractive Nuisance,   The Three Kinds of Being: The Nature of Stories, The High Victorian and the Late Victorian,  Tara Westover's Educated,   The Stratification of Disability,  The Philosophy of Education,   Jane Austen's Conservatism,  Sargent and Beauty, Chomsky’s Imperialism, Grand Themes in Literature

A Short Post On: The Iran War is a personal and political  diversion, The Epstein story is not a conspiracy, Ukraine, Race, DEI, Impeachment, Taxes, Gaza, Shutdown, One Month In

Rerelease, a Fresh Take on Timeless Columns: Why Noam Chomsky Is Wrong, Comedy and Tragedy in Pride and Prejudice, Shakespeare's Greatest Melodramas, The Fundamentals of Social Roles,  Kahneman's Fallacies, Thinking, Fast and Slow

Archives: Art Criticism,  Jane Austen,  Shakespeare,  Philosophy,  Literature,  Social Structure,  Religion,  Politics, Everyday Life,  Roles,  Film,  War,  Education,  Favorites, and  Primers.

No results found

To receive a brief e mail about new posts, go here.

For The Duration

August 15, 2021

“For the duration” was a term coined, I believe, during the Second World War to describe the extraordinary measures that had to be taken until the war was over. That included rationing, blackout curtains, a military draft, men away from their homes in dangerous places and women who had to raise children among other women, and women who worked in factories and retail establishments and as government workers and all the women expected to give up their work and take up normal civilian life after the war, which meant getting married, having children and being homemakers. The idea was that things would get back to normal even though it rarely happens when a war ends. The chasm in America today is not only between blacks and whites and college educated and not but also because of the Vietnam War that separated the differences between those who trust the government and those who do not, even though what happened was that the Liberals and what became the Progressives are the more trusting of the government while the Conservatives are the ones who don’t trust to vaccines or elections. 

Things changed a lot after the Second World War. To name some of the standard ones, there was the GI Bill of Rights that made the working class college educated and therefore middle class. There were the suburbs where the middle class could live. There were more and more women in the professions and any number of other walks of life, belying the idea that they would stay at home. There were the minority ethnic groups-- the Jews, the Italians, the Blacks, who pushed their ways into prominence. The nation after the war ended was transformed, but it is fair to say that the wartime measures were ended: no ration cards (though the English retained them into the Fifties); no massive draft and the draft done only gingerly and especially in Vietnam because of its political resistance to that), No shortages as America was able to produce for the world until Europe and Japan recovered and built new manufacturing.on their own. The country grew after the duration was over and American society moved on to other things, like television or women freed from reproductive burdens and so to abolish a double standard of sexual activity.

There are other periods to which can be applied “for the duration”. The present coronavirus pandemic is one of these. Some things had to be suspended or applied because of it, such as masks, or limited dining, or communal events like beaches or concert halls, as well as a high rate of deaths, people not being as patient about the temporary circumstances that had to apply as they were willing to do during the Second World War, commentators noting that people became quickly frustrated at their isolation, for example, though I do not note that as a revelation about the nature of people, which is that they need to converse with strangers or just see the faces of people as they walk past. It isn’t human nature that requires it to find the duration so difficult. The privations in World War Two were more onerous. Rather, the explanation seems to me that the political framework has changed from loyalty to distrust. Who the hell are those people telling you what to do? Wearing masks is a privation of liberty and it would be worthless to explain that “liberty” has something to do with political liberty, the ability to vote or to express your opinion, rather than use the public health measures that have been in place to control epidemics for six hundred years now., since the Black Plague. 

And so it is even more unsettling for people to find that what was really a short plague year of a year and a half from the time it began in January, 2020, and which peaked in New York that April, when it seemed that there would be no respirators left in New York and we were planning to fill a hospital ship with coronavirus patients, and then the crisis abated, and people began to get vaccinated in January of 2021, expecting it to be all over by summer, when the Delta variant arose and people, especially in the South, were resistant to getting shots. So the duration is longer and it is their own fault. Nobody thought that refusing to get the Sabin vaccine against polio was thought to be a political situation when it became available in 1962 and to be ingested on sugar cubes. Everyone complied as a matter of good sense. Well, uneducated voters went Democratic during the New Deal because it was in their economic and ethnic issues to do so and the unions reminded them of that. What has changed? Are people dumber or less trained or is it the influence of Trump having corrupted the ability to think clearly?

Not every set of events, mind you, lasts only so long as the constraints on them persist, nt solidified with its new customs and beliefs. and so the war and the pandemic are properly to be regarded as being for the duration. Other social changes are not supposed to ever lapse but to have themselves created or altered the new situation. I am thinking of the Civil Rights Movement which once and for all would end the widespread caste system whereby Blacks were exploited and stigmatized. This was to be an ending rather than a dispensation, and so it seemed to happen in that the Voting Rights Bill and the Equal Accomdations Act led to black empowerment and the decrease of overt discrimination. Never again to go back to the old days. This was a permanent improvement. And so it is very unsettling to me that there is an attempt to reverse what seemed the irreversible by restricting voting rights in those Southern states that were the ones that had needed pre-clearance to insure that there was no hanky panky in voting so as to disenfranchise Black and brown peoples, the Civil Rights Era to be thought of as subject for revanchment or some other political term that denotes a reversal of trends rather than the establishment of a new institutional arrangements.

Here is another term for a quality of time that does not suspend time, which is what happens in a duration,or changes social structure crucially and dramatically, such as happens in “revolutions”, though I would not refer to the Civil Rights Movement as a revolution because it was not an attempt to change government but to work within government so as to change the society, revolutions like the Russian and the Cuban Revolutions coming into bad odor even though the American Revolution was a salutary and progressive thing, given that colonists became citizens rather than subjects and government based on the will of the people rather than whomever are the powers that be. Let us just call the Civil Rights Movement as a change agent capable of altering institutions and cultures without violence. 

The third term I add is “transition” which is a period during which a society moves from one balance of its forces to another and then restabilizes and perhaps on the equivalent situations that obtained before the transition. Hopefully, the Civil Rights Movement was just a transition between white dominance to another period of white dominance and that does seem unlikely in that the demographic changes will mean that people of color will be the majority minority and that it is the white people who will be in the transition they resent where Black and female faces become everywhere and are not willing to accept that until, eureka, they are everywhere and so inconsequential, as is the case with women U. S. Senators (there are about twenty of them in the hundred person Senate) even if it is true that as of yet women have not broken through the ultimate glass ceiling and become President. Hillary was a transitional figure in that she acclimated the notion of many to a woman President but there was so much animosity towards her that she couldn’t make the final hurdle herself. 

A good example of a transitional time is upward mobility for access to higher education. Let us think of that period as encompassing the time when the G I Bill allowed the working class veterans to go to college when before the war maybe only a few percent of college age students got to college. Extend it to the meritocratic years which allowed white ethnics to make it into Ivy League schools in the Fifties through the Eighties, and then consider the restored alignment whereby very expensive tuitions later on meant that elite institutions are recruited from the rich and Affirmative Action candidates, putting aside the middle class and having them go to state rather than private institutions or local rather than national institutions. That new equilibrium makes education less a mechanism for upward mobility rather than a replication of social class, which is what it had been beforehand the transition. Joe Biden is not trying to change that new equilibrium, to either extend or alter the transition period. As laudatory as his goals can be, a free community college system puts people within their social class background so as to get the education they need to hold down the jobs suited to their backgrounds, this time as nurses aides and bookkeepers rather than as the products of vocational high schools whereby working class kids became auto mechanics and printers. The occupations change but the arrangement of the social classes do not and just return to the class hierarchy of the past.But doing that is worth doing so as to staff the new occupations and give people their livings. 

Here is another use of the term “for the duration” which refers to the personal rather than societal but also refers to a brief or at least limited period of time when exigencies are necessary but will come to an end. I refer to decisions I make or situations I manage as “for the duration”, which means for so long as I live. A person has a stent put in that will last enough until the person dies. A friend of mine had been rejiggering and replacing his hearing aids, ever frustrated by those dang things, until he died, and so the duration was over. He didn’t have to worry about his hearing aids. I get a dental appliance that will last for the duration, as are my housing arrangements, however pleasant, are different and so somehow temporary, than was the place I lived in for forty years with my wife, that not a suspended duration but the substance of life, of a life, which ended when she died and so moved me into lasting until the duration. Makeshift matters, I surmise, will do for a duration but not satisfactory for a fully lived life. You can be more feeble and less full of your powers or influence or major roles in life, like being a husband or a father or a professor. Rather, things, whether social arrangements or even cultural ones, such as how to manage the latest technology, are jerry rigged or not fully used. It is not necessary to do everything on my cell phone even if I read real books so as to read novels. What will do will do. 

Now it is unclear that being under the sway of a duration means me to declutter my life or to get at essentials or that I had progressed to a point where I stopped. I have never gone beyond popular culture when the Eighties took hold though I now get involved with things from the past of that, the Big Band Era, but that was my affinity from the time I was a child, when the Big Band Era was ending. In short, it is to question whether some things are advanced rather than just reduced, and literature does not help me out with that. Dante encapsulated people by the moments of their worst moments and so largely in whatever were the great times in their life. I am wondering how to discuss the terrain that occupies the downward slope that ends when people no longer endure. Do they become wise and serene, like Oedipus? Or nasty, like Sarah? Or more and more distracted, relying on his instincts, like the last few years for FDR, still able to call one off, as to get the best deal possible at Yalta? The future remains a mystery to me. Lear never got old. He just had to deal with altered and diminished circumstances and even had to endure the death of his favorite child, something no one should have to endure and yet happened very late in his life. Either the curse or the bonus of having endured even more.


In EVERYDAY LIFE, SOCIAL STRUCTURE Tags "For the duration"; covid pandemic; social change; temporary arrangements; old age
← Morals and the TalibanA Bit of Decoration →

Latest Posts

Featured
FILM
Black and White Morals
FILM
Read more →
FILM
POLITICS, EVERYDAY LIFE
Ambiguities in Languague
POLITICS, EVERYDAY LIFE
Read more →
POLITICS, EVERYDAY LIFE
POLITICS, PRIMERS
A Short Primer in Socialism
POLITICS, PRIMERS
Read more →
POLITICS, PRIMERS
POLITICS
A Short Post on Trump
POLITICS
Read more →
POLITICS
LITERATURE
Generic Reading Practices
LITERATURE
Read more →
LITERATURE
JANE AUSTEN
Janeites
JANE AUSTEN
Read more →
JANE AUSTEN
LITERATURE, WAR
Propaganda in World War II
LITERATURE, WAR
Read more →
LITERATURE, WAR
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
The Assassination Attempt
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
Read more →
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
POLITICS, WAR
Spheres of Influence
POLITICS, WAR
Read more →
POLITICS, WAR
PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS
Metaphysics at the Supreme Court
PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS
Read more →
PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS
LITERATURE, RELIGION
Dante's Immorality
LITERATURE, RELIGION
Read more →
LITERATURE, RELIGION
POLITICS
Constitutionalism Two
POLITICS
Read more →
POLITICS
SOCIAL STRUCTURE
A Social Scorecard
SOCIAL STRUCTURE
Read more →
SOCIAL STRUCTURE
PHILOSOPHY, RELIGION
Genres of Social Theory
PHILOSOPHY, RELIGION
Read more →
PHILOSOPHY, RELIGION
POLITICS, WAR
Experiments in Regime Change
POLITICS, WAR
Read more →
POLITICS, WAR
POLITICS
A Short Post on Organizing
POLITICS
Read more →
POLITICS
POLITICS, WAR
A Third Short Post on Iran
POLITICS, WAR
Read more →
POLITICS, WAR
WAR, POLITICS
Another Short Post on Iran
WAR, POLITICS
Read more →
WAR, POLITICS
POLITICS, WAR
A Short Post on Iran
POLITICS, WAR
Read more →
POLITICS, WAR
RELIGION, LITERATURE
Creation Fables
RELIGION, LITERATURE

The stories earliest listed in “Genesis” are fables rather than myths and so disclose a higher level of consciousness than to be found with myths.

The creation story in “Genesis” is a far more modern thing than it is usually credited with being  It is a kind of philosophical presentation and so very different from mythology which, as Ovid, that great student of mythology, noted, there are always biological transformations of things even while the gods remain subject to the forces of nature and the raging of human passions. Narcissus may become his image only symbolically, and not all narcissists become their images, but these are still myths because of the element of biological transformation.. The stories that follow the creation story are best explained, on the other hand, as fables, which are stories that explain a set of circumstances that do not seem to be created but which somehow were at a point in time and have become part of nature. Tigers have stripes and the Red Man got baked right, neither too dark or too light.. Fables suggest that there is a history for what seems natural, a sometimes serious, sometimes fey attempt to make explicable what seems not to need explanation or else to make explicable something which seems paradoxical: how something could come into existence when it already had to be there. Good examples of fables that follow soon after the creation story are the tower of Babeel, which is an exaggeration of what people can build and what happens to them, which is to have multilingual peoples, or Noah’s ark, which is an exaggeration of a boat that could be built rather than transforming animals so they could swim.

Read more →
RELIGION, LITERATURE
FILM, LITERATURE
"The Night Manager"
FILM, LITERATURE

John Le Carre is a serious novelist.

The secret of spy novels and movies is that they describe ordinary people doing universal things, however exotic is the setting and the premises are and that the people act outside the law. People can’t escape from or suspend their human nature evgen if they think they are beyond the restraints of the law. A good or even exemplary item of that is available in Conrad’s “The Secret Agent” where an anarchist wanders around London with bombs wrapped around him under his coat feeling comforted that at any moment he could explode himself. That seems bizarre or crazy until the reader recognizes that this is a kind of freedom. The anarchist has freedom to destroy himself which is an ultimate freedom because his control over it is absolute and without the constraint of others, purely subject to personal will. All people want to some extent to do what they want, to say fuck you to the world however ugly it may be and that gets externalized in the image of that anarchist.

Read more →
FILM, LITERATURE
POLITICS
A Short Post on Epstein
POLITICS
Read more →
POLITICS
CoverStory-TOMINE_PostVacation.jpg.webp
ART CRITICISM
New Yorker Covers
ART CRITICISM
Read more →
ART CRITICISM
updike.jpg
RELIGION, LITERATURE
Updike's "Toward the End of Time"
RELIGION, LITERATURE

The first of a two part post on John Updike’s “Toward the End of Time” through the analysis of generic types.                                                                                                    

Persistently undervalued, except perhaps for his Rabbit novels, because he is regarded as covering up facile meaning with an engaging writing style, the quintessential New Yorker writer, John Updike deserves more appreciation, even in one of his lesser novels : Toward the End of Time”. But in order to appreciate the novel’s achievement, step back a few steps and consider the kind of book it is, which is what I call a deficient epic. Updike is very careful about what each of her novels are, whether the saga of “In the beauty of the lilies” or the polemical politics of “Terrorist” or “Couples” as the romantic serio-comedy.

Read more →
RELIGION, LITERATURE
RELIGION
Noah the Technologist
RELIGION
Read more →
RELIGION
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
The Battle of Minneapolis
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
Read more →
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
Audrey old and youn.jpg
ART CRITICISM, PHILOSOPHY
Celebrity Images of Old Age
ART CRITICISM, PHILOSOPHY
Read more →
ART CRITICISM, PHILOSOPHY
POLITICS, PHILOSOPHY
Three Kinds of Government
POLITICS, PHILOSOPHY

Why there are only three kinds of government--monarchy, legislative authority, and mob rule--is a good question.

There are only three kinds of government. All the other types are variations of the three however spectacular some of them may be. The three types can be found in Aristotle’s “Politics”. There are governments controlled by the upper classes, and those can be dictatorial. There are those run by the middle class, and those are sensible and responsible. There are those controlled by the lower classes and that results in mob rule. The modern formulation was identified in the seventeenth century by Spinoza who identified there to be monarchies, which rested in agriculture, governments led by legislatures, which are based on commerce, and charismatic governments led by mob rule.. Consider the basic types and their variations.

Read more →
POLITICS, PHILOSOPHY
RELIGION, LITERATURE
Adam and Eve
RELIGION, LITERATURE

The story of Adam andEve work as fables, while the storyu of Samson and Delilah work as romance.

The creation of a woman should not be seen as an afterthought by a God who had previously provided each of his animals with a mate but overlooked doing it for Adam. God may have thought that Adam was a special enough creation, meant to rule over the rest of it, and so he did not need a mate. But either God changed his mind about that or always knew that he would make a special creation later. Woman was a special creation so as to emphasize that in the actual world the relation between man and woman is not like it is with the pairings of the other animals; some special kind of creation was required. Eve was as close to Adam as his own rib. As a legend might, the story of Eve’s creation suggests that woman has thereafter an ambiguous relation to man: part of him, descended from him, and yet a companion to him, and so clearly something different from what happens with some other created species no matter how much it might occur to a son of Adam or a daughter of Eve that the two sexes had different natures. We can see this more clearly if we consider the type of literary undertaking the story of the Garden of Eden is.

Read more →
RELIGION, LITERATURE
RELIGION
Genealogy and "Genesis"
RELIGION

Longevity is a weighty matter in “Genesis” and beyond.

The geneologies listed in “Genesis” are usually treated as filler so as to show the passage of time, allowing the reader to get to the next juicy story. but the geneologies have literary weight in themselves even though most of the names listed in the “Genesis” genealogies do not have stories associated with them. These people are described only by their lineage and their longevity. The genealogies would seem to say that in those distant times men were indeed titans. How are they titans? “Genesis” says it is not a matter of size or of wisdom or of language or of power but a matter of age. Descent simply ties together people noteworthy for how long they lived.

Read more →
RELIGION

Stories & Analysis of the Intersection of Culture & Social Structure

© 2016 -2024 Martin Wenglinsky