• JOURNAL
  • ARCHIVE
  • ABOUT
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • CONTACT
Menu

Wenglinsky Review

Culture, Social Structure & Politics from a Sociology Professor
  • JOURNAL
  • ARCHIVE
  • ABOUT
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • CONTACT

Ellsworth Kelly, Blue White, 1962. Oil on canvas. Rose Art Museum.

Thought-Provoking Essays Include: Continuous Disabilities, Fascist Science Fiction, The Politics of Drag Queens, Thomas Cole’s The Voyage of Life,  The Fundamentals of Social Roles,  Radical Sociology,   Women Are An Attractive Nuisance,   The Three Kinds of Being: The Nature of Stories, The High Victorian and the Late Victorian,  Tara Westover's Educated,   The Stratification of Disability,  The Philosophy of Education,   Jane Austen's Conservatism,  Sargent and Beauty, Chomsky’s Imperialism, Grand Themes in Literature

A Short Post On: The Iran War is a personal and political  diversion, The Epstein story is not a conspiracy, Ukraine, Race, DEI, Impeachment, Taxes, Gaza, Shutdown, One Month In

Rerelease, a Fresh Take on Timeless Columns: Why Noam Chomsky Is Wrong, Comedy and Tragedy in Pride and Prejudice, Shakespeare's Greatest Melodramas, The Fundamentals of Social Roles,  Kahneman's Fallacies, Thinking, Fast and Slow

Archives: Art Criticism,  Jane Austen,  Shakespeare,  Philosophy,  Literature,  Social Structure,  Religion,  Politics, Everyday Life,  Roles,  Film,  War,  Education,  Favorites, and  Primers.

No results found

To receive a brief e mail about new posts, go here.

An Old Man and his Grandson, ca. 1490, by Domenico Ghirlandaio. Tempera on panel, 62.7 cm x 46.3 cm. Louvre, Paris

An Old Man and his Grandson, ca. 1490, by Domenico Ghirlandaio. Tempera on panel, 62.7 cm x 46.3 cm. Louvre, Paris

Renaissance Portraits at the Met

March 16, 2018

The exhibit of Renaissance portraiture that was on view at the Metropolitan Museum of Art some years ago allows a reconsideration of the tag line from Jacob Burckhardt that the Renaissance saw the birth of individualism. Commentators and art historians at the time of the show invoked Burckhardt as a way to explain what this show was about, even if they used Burckhardt as little more than a mandatory reference: oh yes, his name has to be mentioned, and if the show is not about individualism, what could it be about? Well, it was about the fact that some very, very beautiful pictures had been created; that’s what it was about. Look at the pictures rather than treat them as way stations in intellectual history. Moreover, instead of playing the game of periodicizing art, let us now be analytic and so associate different aspects of art to different aspects of individualism, presuming the forms of individualism to be present at the same time, just as the various features of any art work, such as its subject and composition and its conventions and the external knowledge brought to a painting, are also always all there at the same time. Perhaps not all concepts can be broken down into these four parts, but individualism certainly can be. If that is the case, that the concept of individualism has all the elements that go into visualization, then that is evidence that individualism is not just a concept but a description of something that actually exists in that it can be visualized, while other concepts, such as justice and God, cannot be visualized, and so perhaps do not exist at all.

Read More
In ART CRITICISM Tags Renaissance; Botticelli; individualism; beauty
1 Comment

Latest Posts

Featured
FILM
Black and White Morals
FILM
Read more →
FILM
POLITICS, EVERYDAY LIFE
Ambiguities in Languague
POLITICS, EVERYDAY LIFE
Read more →
POLITICS, EVERYDAY LIFE
POLITICS, PRIMERS
A Short Primer in Socialism
POLITICS, PRIMERS
Read more →
POLITICS, PRIMERS
POLITICS
A Short Post on Trump
POLITICS
Read more →
POLITICS
LITERATURE
Generic Reading Practices
LITERATURE
Read more →
LITERATURE
JANE AUSTEN
Janeites
JANE AUSTEN
Read more →
JANE AUSTEN
LITERATURE, WAR
Propaganda in World War II
LITERATURE, WAR
Read more →
LITERATURE, WAR
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
The Assassination Attempt
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
Read more →
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
POLITICS, WAR
Spheres of Influence
POLITICS, WAR
Read more →
POLITICS, WAR
PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS
Metaphysics at the Supreme Court
PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS
Read more →
PHILOSOPHY, POLITICS
LITERATURE, RELIGION
Dante's Immorality
LITERATURE, RELIGION
Read more →
LITERATURE, RELIGION
POLITICS
Constitutionalism Two
POLITICS
Read more →
POLITICS
SOCIAL STRUCTURE
A Social Scorecard
SOCIAL STRUCTURE
Read more →
SOCIAL STRUCTURE
PHILOSOPHY, RELIGION
Genres of Social Theory
PHILOSOPHY, RELIGION
Read more →
PHILOSOPHY, RELIGION
POLITICS, WAR
Experiments in Regime Change
POLITICS, WAR
Read more →
POLITICS, WAR
POLITICS
A Short Post on Organizing
POLITICS
Read more →
POLITICS
POLITICS, WAR
A Third Short Post on Iran
POLITICS, WAR
Read more →
POLITICS, WAR
WAR, POLITICS
Another Short Post on Iran
WAR, POLITICS
Read more →
WAR, POLITICS
POLITICS, WAR
A Short Post on Iran
POLITICS, WAR
Read more →
POLITICS, WAR
RELIGION, LITERATURE
Creation Fables
RELIGION, LITERATURE

The stories earliest listed in “Genesis” are fables rather than myths and so disclose a higher level of consciousness than to be found with myths.

The creation story in “Genesis” is a far more modern thing than it is usually credited with being  It is a kind of philosophical presentation and so very different from mythology which, as Ovid, that great student of mythology, noted, there are always biological transformations of things even while the gods remain subject to the forces of nature and the raging of human passions. Narcissus may become his image only symbolically, and not all narcissists become their images, but these are still myths because of the element of biological transformation.. The stories that follow the creation story are best explained, on the other hand, as fables, which are stories that explain a set of circumstances that do not seem to be created but which somehow were at a point in time and have become part of nature. Tigers have stripes and the Red Man got baked right, neither too dark or too light.. Fables suggest that there is a history for what seems natural, a sometimes serious, sometimes fey attempt to make explicable what seems not to need explanation or else to make explicable something which seems paradoxical: how something could come into existence when it already had to be there. Good examples of fables that follow soon after the creation story are the tower of Babeel, which is an exaggeration of what people can build and what happens to them, which is to have multilingual peoples, or Noah’s ark, which is an exaggeration of a boat that could be built rather than transforming animals so they could swim.

Read more →
RELIGION, LITERATURE
FILM, LITERATURE
"The Night Manager"
FILM, LITERATURE

John Le Carre is a serious novelist.

The secret of spy novels and movies is that they describe ordinary people doing universal things, however exotic is the setting and the premises are and that the people act outside the law. People can’t escape from or suspend their human nature evgen if they think they are beyond the restraints of the law. A good or even exemplary item of that is available in Conrad’s “The Secret Agent” where an anarchist wanders around London with bombs wrapped around him under his coat feeling comforted that at any moment he could explode himself. That seems bizarre or crazy until the reader recognizes that this is a kind of freedom. The anarchist has freedom to destroy himself which is an ultimate freedom because his control over it is absolute and without the constraint of others, purely subject to personal will. All people want to some extent to do what they want, to say fuck you to the world however ugly it may be and that gets externalized in the image of that anarchist.

Read more →
FILM, LITERATURE
POLITICS
A Short Post on Epstein
POLITICS
Read more →
POLITICS
CoverStory-TOMINE_PostVacation.jpg.webp
ART CRITICISM
New Yorker Covers
ART CRITICISM
Read more →
ART CRITICISM
updike.jpg
RELIGION, LITERATURE
Updike's "Toward the End of Time"
RELIGION, LITERATURE

The first of a two part post on John Updike’s “Toward the End of Time” through the analysis of generic types.                                                                                                    

Persistently undervalued, except perhaps for his Rabbit novels, because he is regarded as covering up facile meaning with an engaging writing style, the quintessential New Yorker writer, John Updike deserves more appreciation, even in one of his lesser novels : Toward the End of Time”. But in order to appreciate the novel’s achievement, step back a few steps and consider the kind of book it is, which is what I call a deficient epic. Updike is very careful about what each of her novels are, whether the saga of “In the beauty of the lilies” or the polemical politics of “Terrorist” or “Couples” as the romantic serio-comedy.

Read more →
RELIGION, LITERATURE
RELIGION
Noah the Technologist
RELIGION
Read more →
RELIGION
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
The Battle of Minneapolis
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
Read more →
POLITICS, SOCIAL STRUCTURE
Audrey old and youn.jpg
ART CRITICISM, PHILOSOPHY
Celebrity Images of Old Age
ART CRITICISM, PHILOSOPHY
Read more →
ART CRITICISM, PHILOSOPHY
POLITICS, PHILOSOPHY
Three Kinds of Government
POLITICS, PHILOSOPHY

Why there are only three kinds of government--monarchy, legislative authority, and mob rule--is a good question.

There are only three kinds of government. All the other types are variations of the three however spectacular some of them may be. The three types can be found in Aristotle’s “Politics”. There are governments controlled by the upper classes, and those can be dictatorial. There are those run by the middle class, and those are sensible and responsible. There are those controlled by the lower classes and that results in mob rule. The modern formulation was identified in the seventeenth century by Spinoza who identified there to be monarchies, which rested in agriculture, governments led by legislatures, which are based on commerce, and charismatic governments led by mob rule.. Consider the basic types and their variations.

Read more →
POLITICS, PHILOSOPHY
RELIGION, LITERATURE
Adam and Eve
RELIGION, LITERATURE

The story of Adam andEve work as fables, while the storyu of Samson and Delilah work as romance.

The creation of a woman should not be seen as an afterthought by a God who had previously provided each of his animals with a mate but overlooked doing it for Adam. God may have thought that Adam was a special enough creation, meant to rule over the rest of it, and so he did not need a mate. But either God changed his mind about that or always knew that he would make a special creation later. Woman was a special creation so as to emphasize that in the actual world the relation between man and woman is not like it is with the pairings of the other animals; some special kind of creation was required. Eve was as close to Adam as his own rib. As a legend might, the story of Eve’s creation suggests that woman has thereafter an ambiguous relation to man: part of him, descended from him, and yet a companion to him, and so clearly something different from what happens with some other created species no matter how much it might occur to a son of Adam or a daughter of Eve that the two sexes had different natures. We can see this more clearly if we consider the type of literary undertaking the story of the Garden of Eden is.

Read more →
RELIGION, LITERATURE
RELIGION
Genealogy and "Genesis"
RELIGION

Longevity is a weighty matter in “Genesis” and beyond.

The geneologies listed in “Genesis” are usually treated as filler so as to show the passage of time, allowing the reader to get to the next juicy story. but the geneologies have literary weight in themselves even though most of the names listed in the “Genesis” genealogies do not have stories associated with them. These people are described only by their lineage and their longevity. The genealogies would seem to say that in those distant times men were indeed titans. How are they titans? “Genesis” says it is not a matter of size or of wisdom or of language or of power but a matter of age. Descent simply ties together people noteworthy for how long they lived.

Read more →
RELIGION

Stories & Analysis of the Intersection of Culture & Social Structure

© 2016 -2024 Martin Wenglinsky